Sign up today for an exclusive discount along with our 30-day GUARANTEE — Love us or leave, with your money back! Click here to become a part of our growing community and learn how to stop gambling with your investments. We will teach you to BE THE HOUSE — Not the Gambler!

Click here to see some testimonials from our members!

Value Investing Is Not Dead, But It Is Harder

By David Trainer. Originally published at ValueWalk.

For quite some time, traditional value investing has not seemed to work. Even Goldman Sachs, the bluest of blue blood firms, recently wrote that “value investing is dead”. There are many theories explaining the demise, but the most popular one was recently voiced by legendary value investor Jeremy Grantham in his first quarter letter to investors for 2017. In it, he tells investors, “This Time Seems Very, Very Different,” and the famous perma-bear flips his long-time bearish script and argues that valuations may stay elevated for many years to come. Mr. Grantham succumbs, finally, to the idea that the old rules of value investing may no longer apply

.Jason Karp’s Tourbillon Capital: FAANGs Are Not Investments; Bubbles Everywhere

Mr. Grantham’s arguments for the end of traditional value investing parallel those of many investors. They rest primarily on the assertions that both corporate profit margins and, consequently, valuations are permanently higher. Grantham says that he’s done waiting for this divergence to resolve, and he’s ready to accept a “new normal” of higher profit margins and valuation.

More rigorous analysis reveals flaws in those assertions, which suffer from reliance on accounting results that ignore financial footnotes and balance sheets. A more rigorous look at corporate profits shows them declining, not rising. Furthermore, when put into a richer historical context, stock valuations are rising, but they are still lower than anytime in the last 15 years.

Get The Full Walter Schloss Series in PDF

Get the entire 10-part series on Walter Schloss in PDF. Save it to your desktop, read it on your tablet, or email to your colleagues.

We respect your email privacy

Walter Schloss

Virtual Currencies – Not Just Bitcoin And Ethereum – Here Are Some Other Notable Names

We think today’s market is the best in many years for value investors, the real value investors, that is. The real value investors analyze footnotes and balance sheets in addition to income statements.

Flaw #1: Margins and Profits Are Much Higher Than Ever Before

Grantham’s thesis on value investing no longer working starts with the assertion that the average profit margin for the S&P 500 is ~30% higher over the past twenty years than it was any time prior.

On the contrary, we see a real decline in corporate profits in recent years as we demonstrated in The Earnings Recovery Is An Illusion. The difference in our perspective and that of Mr. Grantham comes from our analysis of the footnotes and balance sheets in addition to the earnings numbers he gets from income statements.

Figure 1 shows the steady decline of economic earnings over the past few years even as reported earnings are up slightly.

Finding Hidden Value Stocks In Japan

Value Investing

Grantham bases his conclusions on earnings reported under Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP). GAAP earnings contain numerous loopholes that companies can exploit to manipulate results. Only by digging through the financial footnotes and management discussion and analysis (MD&A) can investors reverse these accounting distortions to get an accurate picture of corporate profitability.

The same mistake is made by Goldman Sachs when they focus on the “value factor” or free cash flow. This metric is based on a simple concept, but an accurate calculation requires many complex and subtle adjustments to reported accounting results if you want both an accurate and apples-to-apples measure of free cash flow.

In addition to the issues with manipulation and comparability, accounting earnings only cover the income statement, which means they’re only telling a fraction of the whole story. A truly comprehensive analysis of corporate profitability must focus on both the operating profit (NOPAT) generated by the company and the amount of invested capital (recorded on the balance sheet and in the footnotes) required to generate NOPAT.

Just How Did Walter Schloss Achieve A 21.3% CAGR From 1956 To 1984

Value Investing

We don’t have machine-readable filings going back far enough to completely test Grantham’s claims, but Figure 2 does show that NOPAT margins have been flat over the past few years for the S&P 500. However, invested capital turns (i.e. capital efficiency as measured by dividing revenue by average invested capital) have declined.

Grantham makes some good points about the declining rate of business startups in the U.S. and how regulations create barriers to entry that protect the largest corporations. It does appear that these anticompetitive trends will allow big U.S. companies to hold on to some excess economic value, but Figure 1 suggests that competitive pressures have kept that value lower than Grantham believes.

Flaw #2: Valuations Are Stretched

The next point in Mr. Grantham’s argument that the traditional rules of value investing no longer apply is the observation that the average P/E ratio for the S&P 500 has been ~70% higher over the past twenty years than for the entire preceding period.

This flaw in this assertion is clear. If your denominator for the P/E ratio is off target, then your ratio cannot be accurate.

Rather than using the flawed accounting results for the P/E ratio, we focus on economic earnings as shown in Figure 1. Economic earnings measure the underlying economic performance of the business. This metric is comprehensive and captures the income statement, balance sheet, cash flow statement, footnotes and other disclosures. It is also leverages the latest in forensic accounting so it is free of accounting distortion.

Is Teaching Beta Unethical? This Professor Thinks So

Value Investing

On the face of it, Figure 3 doesn’t look too troubling. The S&P’s P/EE has more than doubled since 2012, but it’s still below it’s pre-08 levels (and so far below the tech bubble that we couldn’t even include that era on the chart or it would throw off the scale).

However, when you look at Figures 1 and 3 together, the trend becomes more interesting. For several years now, stock prices and accounting earnings have risen while economic earnings have declined. While the overall market may not be as overvalued as Mr. Grantham suggest, it is clear that valuations for many stocks are getting too high.

Value Investing Matters More Than Ever

It’s not just Mr. Grantham that focuses on accounting earnings; so do most investors. As a result, the market tends to be more focused on accounting earnings than economic earnings. In addition, accounting earnings are widely available for free. Economic earnings are not, and they require lots of work to calculate oneself (reading very 10-K and 10-Q cover to cover). So, we understand why so many investors, including Mr. Grantham, focus on accounting earnings instead of economic earnings.

However, heightened awareness of fiduciary duties by both investors and advisors is ushering in a return to the more diligent habits that underpin value investing, e.g. focusing on economic earnings. In addition, now that interest rates are no longer falling, markets no longer have the Fed to bail them out. We also think the reliance on technical research is at or past a cyclical

The post Value Investing Is Not Dead, But It Is Harder appeared first on ValueWalk.

Sign up for ValueWalk’s free newsletter here.


Do you know someone who would benefit from this information? We can send your friend a strictly confidential, one-time email telling them about this information. Your privacy and your friend's privacy is your business... no spam! Click here and tell a friend!





You must be logged in to make a comment.
You can sign up for a membership or get a FREE Daily News membership or log in

Sign up today for an exclusive discount along with our 30-day GUARANTEE — Love us or leave, with your money back! Click here to become a part of our growing community and learn how to stop gambling with your investments. We will teach you to BE THE HOUSE — Not the Gambler!

Click here to see some testimonials from our members!