19.5 C
New York
Wednesday, April 24, 2024

Comment by mplaut

View Single Comment

  1. mplaut

    The full report is available here: http://www1.sky.com/news/irangov2011-6.pdf
    According to the report, it is not based on "laptop documents" but:
    12.  As indicated in paragraph 6 above, among the information available to the Agency is the alleged
    studies documentation: a large volume of documentation (including correspondence, reports, view graphs
    from  presentations,  videos  and  engineering  drawings),  amounting  to  over  a  thousand  pages.  The
    information  reflected  in  that  documentation  is  of  a  technically  complex  and  interconnected  nature,
    showing  research,  development  and  testing  activities  over  time.  It  also  contains  working  level
    correspondence consistent with the day to day implementation of a formal programme. Consistent with the
    Agency’s practice, that information has been carefully and critically examined. The Agency has also had
    several meetings with the Member State to clarify the information it had provided, to question the Member
    State about the forensics it had carried out on the documentation and the information reflected in it, and to
    obtain more information on the underlying sources.
    13.  In addition to the alleged studies documentation, the Agency has received information from more
    than ten Member States. This has included procurement information, information on international travel
    by individuals said to have been involved in the alleged activities, financial records, documents reflecting
    health and safety arrangements, and other documents demonstrating manufacturing techniques for certain
    high explosive components. This information reinforces and tends to corroborate the information reflected
    in the alleged studies documentation, and relates to activities substantially beyond those identified in that
    documentation.
    14.  In addition to the information referred to in paragraphs 12 and 13 above, the Agency has acquired
    information as a result of its own efforts, including publications and articles acquired through open source
    research, satellite imagery, the results of Agency verification activities and information provided by Iran
    in the context of those verification activities.
    22
     Importantly, the Agency has also had direct discussions
    with a number of individuals who were involved in relevant activities in Iran, including, for example, an
    interview with a leading figure in the clandestine nuclear supply network (see paragraph 35 below). The
    information obtained by the Agency from the discussions with these individuals is consistent with the
    information provided by Member States, and that acquired through its own efforts, in terms of time frames
    and technical content.
    15.  As  indicated  in  paragraph 8  above,  Iran  has  acknowledged  certain  information  reflected  in  the
    alleged studies documentation. However, many of the answers given by Iran to questions posed by the
    Agency  in  connection  with  efforts  to  resolve  the  Agency’s  concerns  have  been  imprecise  and/or
    incomplete, and the information has been slow in coming and sometimes contradictory. This, combined
    with events such as the dismantling of the Lavisan-Shian site in late 2003/early 2004 (see paragraph 19
    below), and a pattern of late or after the fact acknowledgement of the existence of previously undeclared
    parts  of  Iran’s nuclear  programme,  have  tended to  increase the  Agency’s  concerns,  rather  than  dispel
    them. 
    16.  As indicated above, the information consolidated and presented in this Annex comes from a wide
    variety  of  independent  sources,  including  from  a  number  of  Member  States,  from  the  Agency’s  own
    efforts and from information provided by Iran itself. It is overall consistent in terms of technical content,
    individuals and organizations involved and time frames. Based on these considerations, and in light of the
    Agency’s general knowledge of the Iranian nuclear programme and its historical evolution, the Agency
    finds the information upon which Part C of this Annex is based to be, overall, credible.



Stay Connected

157,327FansLike
396,312FollowersFollow
2,290SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Articles