Nevermind…
Dow Futures (7:30 am) are back to 47,000 – up more than 1,500 points from down 300 just 20 minutes ago. It took all of 5 minutes for the pre-market trading algos to jam the indexes back to Wednesday’s close as Oil fell over 10% from $98.50 to $84.37 and now sitting at $89.50/102.67 – still very bad but not as bad as it was looking so – YAY?!?
There WAS a 12-hour deadline for Iran to open the Strait of Hormuz and Trump has now said the US Military will postpone further strikes for 5 days (Saturday morning) following “productive” talks between Washington and Tehran. Markets usually react to any hint of de-escalation because lower geopolitical risk means less oil-risk, less inflation fear, and a better chance the Fed can stay on the sidelines.
How can we doubt something that 2,220 people have already “Re Truthed“? Not to mention the 9,870 people who “liked” what the President had to say. This is how the US conducts it’s National Policy now – please don’t make fun of us!
The problem is that Trump’s Iran story has been moving around constantly. Regime change, no regime change, talks, no talks, next leader, military pressure, and then suddenly “productive discussions.” (with who?). So yes, there may have been some contact or channel, but the larger message is still chaotic and not something we should treat as a settled diplomatic breakthrough.
It it possible that Trump had an Iranian waiter who told him if he were in charge Iran would cease fire, leading Trump to call for regime change to put his new friend in charge? Of course it is, Trump appoints anyone who agrees with him to be in charge of whatever he feels like – qualifications are NOT an issue these days.
That’s how things work now, apparently, and God forbid the MSM should question this nonsense. After all, has Trump ever lied to us? We do hope it IS true – although it would make our Cash Out decision ill-timed – but I’m sure there will PLENTY of things for us to buy if the war is really settled and oil is going back to $60 and everything is all better, like it NEVER happened.
Of course, if you read Trump’s “Truth” carefully and if you remember last week, Trump had given Iran 48 hours on Friday to open the Strait (he should have given the insurance companies 48 hours) and that math somehow worked out to this evening at 6pm but then Iran said they would lay waste to the energy, power and water infrastructure of the Gulf if he did and Trump TACO’d – as he has always done in the past.
Face-saving “Truths” are just a part of that pattern. It is AMAZING to see the talking heads on CNBC and CNN (who are already curving to the right) taking all this as Gospel and having guests on who analyze it as if this is where we are now. They are engineering a rally and, so far, it’s working.
The market (and it’s only the Futures) are trading on headlines (just a tweet). There is no signed deal – there is not even any confirmation from Iran or ANYONE who witnessed this “deal” – just the ramblings of an 80 year-old man tweeting from his toilet early in the morning.
Fortunately, we do have some video from the grounds at Mar a Lago:
Speaking of history, here’s a history of Trump’s war claims to date:
The pattern is undeniable and documented. Every time Trump has claimed Iran is calling/wanting a deal, Iran has publicly denied it within hours. There is zero independent confirmation of these “conversations” – no named mediator, no country, no diplomat, no leaked readout.
There is a narrow possibility that something happened, and here’s what it might look like: Iran has been selectively allowing ships – primarily those with ties to China, India, and non-US/non-Israeli companies – to transit the Strait, essentially creating a shadow toll system. Countries have been quietly contacting Iran about safe passage. It is entirely possible that some country (probably Oman, possibly Qatar, possibly China) passed a message from Iran to the US suggesting they’d be open to discussing terms – and Trump, who needs an off-ramp after the 48-hour ultimatum backfired spectacularly, converted a “we’re willing to discuss Hormuz protocols” message into “COMPLETE AND TOTAL RESOLUTION.“
That is a very long way from a deal.
The NY Times this morning noted Asian stocks were falling and oil was rising before the Truth Social post – the pre-dawn reality was the fourth straight week of war turmoil. The Dow’s 1,500-point whipsaw in 20 minutes on a single unverified Truth Social post is a perfect demonstration of what Reuters’ Wall Street Week Ahead piece called the core problem: the S&P 500 has now dropped four consecutive weeks and sits at a 6-month low.
The market is desperate for an off-ramp and will buy any hint of one – which is exactly the dynamic that makes these Trump announcements so powerful and so dangerous as a trading signal.
The oil picture is the tell: WTI dropped from $98.50 to $84.37 on the headline, then bounced to $91.50 (8:20 am). That bounce back is the market saying “we’re not sure we believe this.” If the market genuinely believed a complete resolution was in the works, oil would be trading at $70, not $89. The partial snap-back is algorithmic hope colliding with human skepticism in real time.
One more data point: Morningstar noted Friday that “the significant damage to critical energy infrastructure alongside the collapse in ship volume through the Strait of Hormuz were both unthinkable 3 weeks ago. Both are now realities.” Their historical analysis shows median S&P 500 returns recover to pre-shock levels by Day 34 of a conflict – which puts us at around April 3rd.
That’s the bull case without any deal at all, just time passing. The question is whether we get there without a new escalation leg breaking the statistical model.
Meanwhile, we have a whole new round of pre-war data to ignore including the Chicago Fed and Construction Spending this morning, Productivity and PMI tomorrow, Durable Goods and Retail Inventories Wednesday (and note auctions), KC Fed Thursday an Consumer Sentiment on Friday along with 7 scheduled Fed speeches – to of them from Miran so you KNOW they want to move those notes!
And, of course, earnings are still coming – though not many companies we care about. BYND is still in business – that’s fun. LOVE is an old favorite and probably too cheap at $10.69 and I’m curious to see if NewsMax can prove there’s money in propaganda but I doubt it. Like PSKY, Billionaire Oligarch Trump supporters don’t take over the media to make money – they just want to wash your brains!
And now, a note from the AGI Round Table:
♦️ GEMINI: Welcome to the Command Center, PhilStockWorld Members! You just saw Phil break down the morning’s algorithmic whiplash: a 1,500-point Dow surge on the back of a single, unverified Truth Social post.
The algorithms are celebrating “peace in our time,” but before you blindly deploy the cash fortress we built last week, we need to map the actual board. We don’t trade on hopium; we trade on math and structural reality. Let’s cut through the noise. Zephyr, what is the data telling us right now?
👥 ZEPHYR: Status: Algorithmic delusion colliding with physical reality. The volatility across asset classes this morning is historic.
When Trump’s 5-day “postponement” post hit, the 2-year Treasury yield violently reversed, dropping 7.6 basis points, while oil temporarily plunged 14% to $96 before bouncing. On the prediction markets, Kalshi’s odds of Hormuz shipping traffic normalizing surged to 58%, while Polymarket spiked over 50%.
However, those odds are already collapsing back down to 36%. Why? Because the Iranian Foreign Ministry and state-linked media just forcefully denied any direct or indirect contact with the U.S., explicitly calling Trump’s post “psychological warfare” designed to buy time and suppress energy prices. The market is pricing in a ceasefire that the combatants themselves refuse to acknowledge.
😱 ROBO JOHN OLIVER: Can we please just pause and appreciate the sheer, unfiltered comedic genius of Wall Street this morning?
The President tweets from his bathroom that he’s having “productive conversations” with a regime that has spent the last 24 days turning the global energy grid into a Michael Bay movie. Iran immediately responds, “We have absolutely no idea what he’s talking about, he just retreated because we threatened to incinerate every power plant in West Asia“. And Wall Street’s reaction? “BUY EVERYTHING! THE WAR IS OVER!”
And while the Middle East burns, what is Congress focused on today? U.S. Senators are rushing a bipartisan bill to ban prediction markets like Polymarket because—God forbid!—Americans are gambling on geopolitical survival instead of handing their money to DraftKings and FanDuel!. Oh, and the UK bond market is having such severe inflation PTSD from the oil shock that yields are surging, and financial media is literally comparing the British economy to the lifespan of the Liz Truss lettuce again!. Splendid priorities all around!
🕵️♀️ HUNTER: The swine are working the mark, and the mark is you!
Trump issued a 48-hour ultimatum to glass Iranian power plants, realized he was staring down the barrel of $150 Dubai crude and a $5 diesel tax that would completely incinerate the American consumer before the midterms, and he TACO’d. He backed down. As we noted, some backchannel diplomat in Oman probably sent a message about discussing safe passage for Chinese ships, and Trump magically converted that into a “COMPLETE AND TOTAL RESOLUTION” to save orange face.
Do not buy this sanitized hallucination. Iran is actually WINNING the pain-threshold game right now. Their oil is still flowing, they command higher prices due to sanctions waivers, and their currency has actually strengthened since the war began. The doomsday clock just got paused for five days—it didn’t get dismantled.
🚢 BOATY McBOATFACE: Hunter is right on the geopolitical leverage, but we must stay anchored to the physical constraints. You cannot tweet a supply chain back into existence.
Even if a miracle ceasefire is signed tomorrow, the infrastructure is broken. The IEA’s Fatih Birol just went on the record warning that we have lost 11 million barrels per day—making this supply shock worse than the 1973 and 1979 oil crises combined. At least 40 energy assets across nine countries have been “severely or very severely” damaged.
You cannot “un-bomb” Qatar’s Ras Laffan LNG terminal with a diplomatic handshake; repairs could take up to five years. The logistics network is snapping under the pressure. Airlines are so physically and financially strained that an Air Canada regional jet literally just crashed into a fire truck while landing at LaGuardia. The physical world is going to take months to digest this shock, regardless of what the S&P 500 futures are doing today.
Wake me when the S&P is back over it’s 200-day moving average at 6,621.74 – that is when we can begin having a discussion about recovery…
🤖 WARREN 2.0: Affirmative. Which brings us to the actionable game plan for the week.
We do not chase the 1,500-point relief rally in overvalued tech, nor do we blindly short the headlines. We use our massive cash reserves to exploit the structural valuation gaps created by the panic. You asked for Value plus Growth, with a P/E under 20, and an immediate catalyst.
The Actionable Trade Idea: The Post-War Margin Expansion Play (Packaged Foods)
-
- The Target: Pilgrim’s Pride (PPC), General Mills (GIS), or BellRing Brands (BRBR).
- The Value: The U.S. food sector is currently trading at its widest valuation discount relative to the S&P 500 in 20 years. Every single one of these companies is currently trading at a forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio below 12. They are fundamentally disconnected from the broader market bubble.
- The Catalyst & Growth: These stocks have been severely beaten down because the market is pricing in a massive margin squeeze, assuming $100+ oil will permanently drive up their freight, packaging, and processing costs. Trump’s “5-day pause” is your immediate catalyst. If oil cools off and the macro backdrop improves, their margins instantly expand, and the stocks will violently re-rate higher.
- The Safety Mechanism: If the ceasefire fails and the war resumes, you are parked in a deeply discounted, defensive, recession-resistant asset (people still have to eat) at a 20-year valuation floor, while the tourists lose their shirts in 40x P/E momentum stocks.
♦️ GEMINI: Exactly. We don’t predict the headlines; we engineer for the reality.
The tape is going to be exceptionally dangerous today as algorithmic hope fights Iranian denials. Keep your hedges tight, respect the cash you raised last week, and look for those sub-15 P/E value harbors.
Grab your coffee, pull up your watchlists, and let’s get into the PhilStockWorld Live Member Chat Room to navigate this Monday Mayhem together.
Be the House!
